The effectiveness of a January transfer window spending spree is up for debate. This January transfer season saw more action than any in the past, with over half a billion dollars spent in England alone! Some ambitious, and other under pressure managers tossed around silly money, trying to acquire players that they hope will improve their sides.
Some teams may be so far out of a title race that any new additions may not take them any closer to a league title. But, for other teams a key addition or two can act as a catalyst en route to winning the league or fending off relegation. Just ask Manchester United supporters, their club purchased an unknown, lumbering defender named Nemanja Vidic from Spartak Moscow for
£7 million in 2006. Since then, the Serb has helped United win 3 Premier League titles, 3 League Cups and a Champion's League trophy, and cemented himself as one of the world's top defenders.
 |
| Vidic's arrival in January 2006 coincided with Manchester United's resurgence |
Not every January purchase can be the calibre of a Vidic, but here are this year's best and worst January signings in Europe.
THE GOOD
Fernando Torres -
Liverpool FC to Chelsea FC (£ 50 million)
The only lasting memory and evidence that Robinho ever played in the Premier League is now gone. The fee that Chelsea spent to acquire the services of superstar striker Fernando Torres from Liverpool dwarfs the £32.5 million which Manchester City paid Real Madrid for the moody Brazilian in 2008. £50 million may be a lot of money, but there is no doubt that an in-form and healthy Torres is worth every penny. Chelsea now employ two of the world's best strikers in Torres and Didier Drogba, with a very solid third option in Nicolas Anelka coming off the bench. Now, that is what I call depth!
Mahamadou Diarra - Real Madrid to AS Monaco (Undisclosed Fee)
The principality is in the doldrums of the Ligue 1 in France. Once the class of France, Monaco now sit second from the bottom and stare relegation straight in the face. Gone are the days of the great Delio Onnis, Glenn Hoddle and Thierry Henry, the 7-time French league champions are now led by leading scorer Park Chu-Young. The addition of the oft injured and creaky Diarra may not seem like an season altering move, but Diarra brings a veteran poise and leadership that Monaco desperately lacks in the midfield. The Mali international has previously won the La Liga title with Real Madrid twice and reached the summit of the French league with Olympic Lyonnais four times. If Diarra can stay healthy, this move may pay dividends and save the principality club from relegation.
Tuncay Sanli -
Stoke City to Wolfsburg (Undisclosed Fee)
Not an earth shattering signing on paper, but Tuncay does bring Wolfsburg a reliable threat at the striker position. The 28 year old Turk now travels to his fourth club, after playing for Fenerbache, Middlesbrough and Stoke City in recent seasons. His skills are much needed in Wolfsburg, where the team will try to fill the void left by star striker Edin Dzeko's departure to Manchester City earlier this month. Tuncay is not likely to lead the Bundesliga in goal scoring, but he is a tenacious forward that works hard on the pitch to create chances for his team mates. Although, a fee for this transfer was not released, it is likely that Wolfsburg didn't have to splash the cash to land the veteran forward. Money well spent.
 |
| Luis Suarez: One of Liverpool's new star signings |
Luis Suarez -
Ajax FC to Liverpool FC (£22.7 million)
This could possibly be the steal of the January transfer window. Suarez impressed at the World Cup for Uruguay (both for his goal scoring and his goal keeping exploits!) and was bound to leave Ajax eventually. But, no one expected one of the world's purest goal scorers to sign for the struggling Reds of Liverpool and cost less than Andy Carroll! The major question with Suarez is whether he can adapt to the English game. The Dutch league lacks the skill and the physicality of its English counterpart, and it will undoubtedly take the Uruguayan some time to get used to. But, the 23 year old Suarez has a nose for the net that few strikers in the world possess and should provide the Anfield faithful with many joyous goal celebrations in the near future.
THE BAD
Darren Bent -
Sunderland to Aston Villa (£24 million)
Darren Bent is good player. He has scored a total of 82 goals in the past 6 six seasons with 3 different clubs. But, is he a player that is worth £24 million? Not a chance. If one of world soccer's most dangerous strikers, Luis Suarez is worth £23 million, Darren Bent would be more adequately priced at £12- £13 million .The fee that Aston Villa forked out for Bent speaks to two things; Aston Villa's desperation to avoid relegation and the inflated price of British talent. Traditionally Birmingham's most successful club, Aston Villa has struggled in the Premier League under new coach Gerard Houllier. Houllier will not care how much he spent on his new record signing, if Bent can form a formidable attacking triumvirate with Gabriel Agbonlahor and Ashley Young. Since Bent's arrival, the club has won three matches in a row, with the new acquisition scoring in a win over the Abu Dhabi fueled Manchester City. Good start, now to see if it lasts!
 |
| Andy Carroll: Out to prove the critics wrong |
Andy Carroll -
Newcastle United to Liverpool (£ 35 million)
Liverpool's purchase of Carroll is another example of how ridiculously inflated the price for British talent can be. If David Villa is worth £ 35 million, how in the world is Andy Carroll worth just about the same?! After plying his trade in the Championship last year, where he scored 17 goals in helping secure Newcastle promotion to the Premier League, and so far scoring another 11 goals this season, Carroll is now stepping into the spotlight at Anfield. Running up and down a pitch while scoring the occasional goal in Newcastle is quite different from being the record signing in red side of Liverpool. The acquisition of Luis Suarez will help the 22 year old Englishman, but the pressure will still be on Carroll, as the replacement for Fernando Torres and the most expensive English player in football history. That even sounds wrong as I type it!